Atmospheric Comparisons
This page contains questions about the atmospheres of Earth and Mars.
Participants in the MGS Radio Science Team education outreach program may
answer these questions using the martian meteorological data provided to
them by the MGS Radio Science Team and meteorological data from Earth
collected and recorded by their own class and the other participating classes
in the outreach program. Tools are available on this
Web site for participating students to access and display the data from
Earth and Mars. Students are also encouraged to consult the
lessons and activities on this site for help
in answering the questions. By comparing the meteorological data from the
two planets, much can be learned about the fundamental principles of
atmospheres, weather and climate!
Any comments or questions about the material on this page should be
directed to
joe@nova.stanford.edu.
Questions
- Using the graphical display tools on this site, generate a graph of
the martian surface temperatures recorded by the MGS Radio Science Team.
Also, generate a graph of the surface temperatures on Earth recorded by
your class or one of the other participating classes in the outreach
program (for example, CA0001). If possible, make hard copies of the
surface temperature graphs for Mars and one location on Earth.
- What (approximately) were the three lowest and three highest temperatures
recorded on Mars?
- What (approximately) were the three lowest and three highest temperatures
recorded by one of the participating classes on Earth?
- Based on the high and low temperatures from both Earth and Mars,
which planet would you say is the warmer of the two?
- Give two reasons why one planet is warmer than the other.
- Based on the range of temperatures observed on Mars, how easy or
difficult would it be for life as we know it to survive on the martian
surface?
- Use the graphical display tools again to generate graphs of the
solar longitude (season) and the sub-solar latitude at the time of the
atmospheric measurements. The solar longitude is given in units of
degrees, where (in the northern hemisphere) 0 degrees in
the vernal equinox (first day of spring), 90 degrees is the summer
solstice (first day of summer), 180 degrees is the autumnal equinox
(first day of autumn) and 270 degrees is the winter solstice (first day
of winter). The sub-solar latitude is the latitude of the point on Mars
at which the sun is directly overhead. The sub-solar latitude, of course,
changes with the seasons. At the two equinoxes, the sub-solar latitude is
0 degrees which means that the Sun is directly overhead at the equator.
Make hard copies of the graphs if possible.
- On what day (approximately) was the solar longitude on Mars equal
to 270 degrees?
- What season began on that day in the northern hemisphere of Mars?
- What season began on that day in the southern hemisphere of Mars?
- Why are the seasons different in the northern and southern
hemispheres of Earth and Mars?
- On what day (approximately) did the sub-solar latitude on Mars
reach a minimum?
- Do you think that it is a coincidence that the sub-solar latitude
reaches a minimum on the same day that the solar longitude is 270
degrees? Why or why not?
- How many degrees is Mars tilted relative to the plane in which it
orbits the Sun?
- What do you think is the sub-solar latitude on Earth
when our solar longitude is 270 degrees? 90 degrees? 0 degrees?
- Use the graphical display tools again to generate graphs of the local time
and latitude of the martian atmospheric measurements. Again, make hard copies
of the graphs if possible.
- What (approximately) was the local time on mars of the first martian
atmospheric measurement and what what the local time near the peak in
recorded martian surface temperatures at the beginning of April?
- What (approximately) was the latitude of the first martian atmospheric
measurement and what was the latitude near the peak in recorded martian
surface temperatures at the beginning of April?
- This question is not easy but very important! What season was it on
Mars at the time and place that the first martian atmospheric measurement
was recorded, and what season was it at the time and place of the
measurements recorded near the peak surface temperature at the
beginning of April? Don't forget that the season in the southern
hemisphere is different than that in the northern hemisphere!
- Based on differences in local time, latitude and season, explain
why there is such a large variation in the martian surface temperatures
recorded at the end of January and the beginning of April, 1998.
- What is the typical surface temperature for your
location at the same time of day and in the same season that the first
martian atmospheric measurement was recorded?
- What is the typical surface temperature for your
location at the same time of day and in the same season that the peak
martian surface temperatures were recorded at the beginning of April?
- How and why does surface temperature vary over the course of a day?
- How and why does surface temperature vary with latitude?
- How and why does surface temperature vary with the seasons?
- The next questions concern a phenomenon which exists on Mars but does
not exist on Earth! Observe closely the surface temperatures on Mars from
the peak near the beginning of April 1 until the final measurements in the
middle of April, 1998.
- Using the graphical display tools on this site, generate graphs of
the martian surface pressures recorded by the MGS Radio Science Team and
the elevation of the surface at each of the measurement points with respect to
martian "sea level". Also, generate a graph of the surface pressures on Earth
recorded by your class or one of the other participating classes in the
outreach program (for example, CA0001). If possible, make hard copies of the
surface pressure graphs for Mars and one location on Earth.
- Why is there a difference between the actual surface pressure
measurements from Mars (blue curve on graph of martian surface pressure)
and the estimated pressures at martian sea level (red curve)?
- Does pressure increase or decrease when elevation increases?
- Why does pressure change as it does with elevation?
- Take a look at the atmospheric
pressure profiles which the MGS Radio Science Team has posted, and
make a hard copy of one of them if possible. Does the atmospheric pressure
in the profile vary with elevation as you just said that it should? By
what approximate factor does the pressure change with every 10
kilometer increase in altitude (be careful, the pressure is shown in
the profiles on a logarithmic scale!)?
- Based on the graph of martian surface pressure, what is the
(approximate) average pressure at "sea level" on Mars?
- Based on the graph of surface pressure from your class or one of
the other participating classes in the outreach program, what is the
(approximate) average atmospheric pressure at sea level on Earth?
- Is the average sea level pressure higher on Earth or on Mars? How
many times larger is it?
- Give two reasons why the pressure on Earth is so much different
than it is on Mars?
- Can you explain why water cannot exist in liquid form on Mars? Is
it at all related to the fact that the boiling point of water on Earth
decreases when elevation increases?
- Can you explain why the martian atmosphere does not effectively
filter the ultraviolet rays from the Sun, and why those rays could be
deadly for visitors (or existing life forms!) on the martian surface?
- The next group of questions concern a very interesting martian
atmospheric phenomenon which also does not occur on Earth. The martian
atmosphere is composed primarily of carbon dioxide. During winter, a
significant fraction of the global carbon dioxide freezes out of the
atmosphere onto the polar cap in the winter hemisphere. Atmospheric
pressure decreases at this time. Atmospheric pressure then increases
during the spring in each hemisphere as carbon dioxide sublimates (changes
state from solid to gas) back into the atmosphere.
- Describe the trend in the estimates of martian
surface pressure at the martian "sea level" (red curve of graph of
martian atmospheric pressures).
- On what (approximate) date do the pressures at the martian "sea level"
appear to begin to decrease?
- How does this date compare to the date of the winter solstice in
the northern martian hemisphere?
- By what (approximate) percentage does the pressure at the martian "sea
level" change from the time when it begins to decrease to the end of the
MGS Radio Science Team recording period in the middle of April, 1998?
- Why does the "sea level" pressure change during this period?
- What percentage of the atmosphere is deposited on the winter
(north) polar cap during this period?
- Using the graph of solar longitude at the time of the martian
atmospheric measurements, estimate the date on which spring will begin
in the northern martian hemisphere. Then, estimate what the atmospheric
pressure will be at martian "sea level" on that date. What percentage
of the carbon dioxide in the martian atmosphere will be deposited on
the north martian pole by the end of the northern winter?
- When carbon dioxide is transfered from the martian atmosphere to
one of the martian poles, the planet actually rotates slightly faster!
When the frozen carbon dioxide sublimates back into the atmosphere, the
planet rotates more slowly again. Explain this phenomenon if you can!
Last updated: May 26, 1998
Joe Twicken /
joe@nova.stanford.edu